It takes only one big surprise to make a show unforgettable. At the 56th Annual GMA Dove Awards in Nashville, Ben Fuller started singing “If It Was Up to Me,” his voice calm and strong. Then, without warning, Carrie Underwood walked on stage. The crowd jumped to their feet cheering so loud it felt like the room shook.

Their voices fit together like they were made for each other, steady, warm, and full of feeling. The song talked about trust and letting go, and you could feel that message in every note. Ben’s voice felt honest and deep, while Carrie’s sounded bright and clear.

Carrie Underwood joins Ben Fuller for “If It Was Up to Me” at the GMA Dove Awards

Fans could not stop talking about it afterward. One said it felt like “a piece of heaven landed on stage.” Another said, “This is what happens when two hearts sing the same prayer.” Someone else called it “pure light.” People felt something real that night, something that stayed long after the music stopped.

Carrie and Ben had already performed this song before at the Grand Ole Opry, but this time felt extra special. A few months later, Carrie stepped on another famous stage, but now under the bright lights of New York City. It was New Year’s Eve, and instead of a duet, she was the star leading the party for millions watching at home.

Carrie Underwood – Medley – [2025 Dick Clark’s New Year’s Rockin’ Eve with Ryan Seacrest]

In Times Square, Carrie filled the night with energy and sparkle. She sang “Church Bells,” “Pink Champagne,” and “Before He Cheats,” showing every side of her talent. Each song felt like part of her life story, strong, fun, and fearless. Viewers called it “a powerhouse moment.” It was the kind of show only Carrie could deliver.

Twenty years after winning American Idol, Carrie still sings with heart and purpose. She can move from a quiet country song to a wild pop anthem and never lose who she is. That is what makes her special. Follow Carrie Underwood on Facebook, Instagram and YouTube. Her songs remind us that faith and fire can live in the same voice.